Zune… not quite the ipod killer

May 25, 2008

With the news today of the zune being discontinued from gamestop stores I  thought this would set me up for a quick mindless rant whilst my exams continue to contribute to the currently increasing infrequent use of my blog.

Now when the zune was pre released a lot of people were talking about how it going to change the mp3 player genre instantly- “the ipod killer”… I laughed. My good friend even said “  I thought you of all people would love this?” and this comment  had a good basis in logic as  I am not really a fan of the current market leader. Take the fantastic marketing out of the way and what has the ipod really done differently compared to every cheaper and equally as functional example on the market? Short of forcing you to use itunes (which i will admit has turned into a great music download service) there was nothing, but the point is the Zune was never going to take the crown – not in the first round anyway.

Pre release the Zune sounded great but it was hit by some last minute feature drops  and confusion and we saw it flop. Alas spawned the jokes of “omg that guy has totally got the only Zune in the world” (the fact that this joke was done by at least 100 different people on their one friend who owned a Zune didn’t seem to diminish the humor). The point however was clear; the Microsoft MP3 player took a mere modest chunk out of the apple (groan) and many would see that as the end of it.

I think these people are forgetting something. This is MICROSOFT! They are but one of few companies who have the luxury of getting a launch wrong and doing it again with more money. The Xbox was practically rammed down consumers throats until it became a household name (/item) and now the 360 has continued the growth and  I would be shocked if the next generation of Zune didn’t continue this trend. Will they outsell the ipod in the near future ? no chance! Will they outsell the ipod ever? possibly..  but don’t count the little device out yet at least not while its backed by its big OS selling daddy.

PS. Although hopefully this generation we won’t have more ” coming zune….” adverts.  Meh back to language engineering


Kojima’s Comments on MGS4

April 20, 2008

 

I must admit Hideo Kojima recent comments on Metal Gear Solid 4 confused me a little. For those who don’t know Hideo Kojima is the creator of Metal Gear and in a recent interview with Edge magazine he displayed his disappointment with the most recent game in the series. Now of course one could take this to be modesty; a bit of a perfectionist who feels he could have done better. In fact I think is definitely true to some extent.

  However what puzzled me was how he refereed to the PS3. He stated that when the game was first displayed at TGS the PS3 was a ‘dream machine’ but as time went on his implication seemed to be that he and his team had overestimated the power of the PS3 resulting in a game below his original expectations. He also claimed his team were pushing the Cell Processor to its limit, which I just cannot believe considering how powerful and future proof  Sony claim this multi -core little beauty to be. I suppose this could just be a throw away interview and I should wait till the game is released before passing any serious judgement but just… why on earth would someone say this before release? Unless your trying to make a point?

Meh, I need more coffee…

http://kotaku.com/381412/kojima-disappointed-with-metal-gear-solid-4


Innovation vs Reinvention

April 13, 2008

Ok so the title is probably a little too dramatic for what I’m going to talk about but here goes.  In recent weeks there has been debate on the net regarding developer comments made towards the Xbox 360’s Live Arcade platform.

  These comments suggest that the platform that was originally supposed to allow small time publishers to release titles on the 360 has been taken over by the  big cooperate companies and as such arcade has turned into a platform for rehashes of old games.  Further criticisms were aimed that the majority of remakes were in fact just ports and nowhere near the level of Ubisoft’s Prince of Perisa remake.

  Of course the flip of the coin is that many fans of arcade are often screaming out for their favourite old titles to be brought back with slight improvements like multiplayer. And of course  Microsoft being the company that it is, is going to try and meet demand of its customers.

People aren’t really going to know the names of small arcade games before their released are they? My standpoint is why can’t we have both? Why can’t we have big publishers using licences to bring the games everyone wants to the platform while small time publishers make fresh new games good enough to be on the service. I mean if you just look at Microsoft as just a bloodthirsty  company their not going to turn down a potential big hit just because it came from a smaller developer are they? If anything that would mean they have potentially more leverage in negotiations. As a young programmer I feel if I created a game that was genuinely good and suited to the arcade platform I  would be confident of getting it on live arcade. Why would Microsoft turn away potential revenue that isn’t going to cost them anything?

I guess the point of this post is I don’t see the problem. So if you didn’t want to read the above just read this paragraph. :P  


PS3 DualShock Controllers..

April 2, 2008

The new rumble controllers for the PS3 will be arriving in the US within the next couple of weeks. Least anyone forget the saga it took to get ‘rumble’ on the PS3 following the lawsuit by Immersion in 2002 on grounds of patent infringement. While Microsoft shrewdly chose to settle out of court Sony’s decision to defend left them with $82 million to pay for the 7 years they had been using the rumble technology previous. In addition to this they were no longer allowed to sell any ‘rumble controllers’ for any of their 3 consoles despite an appeal attempt. Sony tried to play this off as a ‘we have outgrown rumble’ marketing ploy, before making a deal with Immersion to gain the rights to include that horribly ancient technology for their net-Gen console. Something their rivals had from the start.

   I will be curious to see sale figures for this controller assuming Sony do not offer to trade in old controllers for free (and I can’t imagine the loss for doing that) as will anyone really want to spend $50 on a new controller? I could make a there’s’ certainly no games buy’ joke here but I’m going to rise above it.


Creative Vista Drivers – a new issue..

March 29, 2008

An interesting situation is developing with the Creative soundcard community in response to Creative’s decision to stop a non Creative employee from distributing modified Creative drivers to enhance user’s Vista experience.

   A user on the Creative forums going by the handle Daniel_K has been modifying the standard Vista drivers provided for various Creative soundcard’s to ensure that features supplied in the driver build actually work on user’s Vista systems. Features such as Decoding of Dolby® Digital and DTS™ signals work fine when installed on a Windows XP machine but the vista driver counterparts do not.

Many Creative soundcard owners have taken up arms against Creative for this with declarations that they will never buy another Creative product again as a result of this decision. The official forum topic is laced with angry users who feel Creative deliberately fixed the Vista drives to not be completely compatible and thus ensure when new ‘Vista’ soundcards are released users will be forced to upgrade. The argument being how could one person make the drivers compatible when a whole Creative team could not?

Creative’s reasoning however becomes more clear when you consider that Daniel_K, whilst providing the fixes for free, has been requesting donations for his contributions. The implication written by a Creative representative in the forums might suggest that Creative was put under pressure by its partners to stop this actions due to fear over IP. After all it is Creative and its affiliate’s IP that is being used in the drivers and the modified drivers are still for the most part Creative software.  Any negative effects of these drivers could reflect poorly on Creative should they cause problems on hardware they were not intended for.

“By enabling our technology and IP to run on sound cards for which it was not originally offered or intended, you are in effect, stealing our goods.  When you solicit donations for providing packages like this, you are profiting from something that you do not own.”

This statement taken from the official statements sums up the Creative standpoint quite nicely.

Personally I’m not sure where  I stand on the matter. One the one hand it seems ridiculous that Creative would step in and shut someone down who is enhancing their product for free. Then again by asking for donations he is walking a very fine line of stealing and putting the Creative label at risk.

   Personally I’d just hire the guy and put him on driver support :P

http://forums.creative.com/creativelabs/board/message?board.id=soundblaster&thread.id=116332&view=by_date_ascending&page=1

The official Thread


Small things that have interested me this week 29/3/08

March 29, 2008

Developers of N+ complaining about Xbox Live arcade being taken over by  the ‘big boys’ and as a results the majority of arcade titles are , shall we say ’sub-par’.

 - Wow strong words. While  I disagree that the majority of  arcade titles are poor (Geo Wars , come on!) there does seem to be a large number big publishers releasing most of the games. The ‘freedom’ for bedroom programmers to release titles has gone a bit wary.

In related new Microsoft is apparently going to to be reducing the amount of “faithful arcade ports” on Xbox live arcade.

-  I found this weird, simply because of how well they are doing. Then again maybe Microsoft are stepping in to ensure a solution to what  I have just stated above.

Comcast are backing down on their traffic ‘meddling’ with Bit-torrent users after an investigation by the FCC.

- The problem I find with restricting file sharing applications is people still use these as places to share legitimate and legal downloads. So by law you cannot discriminate against the whole service. I will be interested to see if ISP action on  this escalates.

This years PWN 2 OWN contest where hackers were allowed to choose one of the 3 major OS’s to hack resulted in the winner hacking MAC OS X after an exploit in Safari.

- I must admit after Apple pushing Safari in their update software to Windows customers last week this made me laugh, although from what I understand the vulnerability would not be present in the Windows version. What’s also interesting is the winner claimed he choose OSX because he knew it would be easiest, i wonder if this exploit was just a one off. 

PS3 Security Vulnerability allowing Hackers to access other peoples account

- With consoles becoming more and more like desktop PC’s with Internet access etc this is going to become more and more likely. Hopefully the Microsoft’s and Sony’s can find a way to keep their console’s security tight without restricting users :) .

Ubisoft purchasing the rights to the “Tom Clancy” brand

- A lot more Ghost Recon and Rainbow Six heading our way it looks: else why buy the brand out? Speaking of Rainbow six the reviews have been pretty steady and it is supposedly like the first with a ‘run’ button. Sounds like I  should pick it up..


It is the job of the Techy to make life idiot proof..

March 27, 2008

My new wireless router arrived today for my family home, which led part of me to begin dreading what was about to happen. Most experiences of routers,switches or what have you have left me with a thorough hatred for the designers who seem to want to ensure only their own company employees can operate them.

  My choice was the D-Link DIR-615 Wireless-N CableDSL Router current delivered for around £50 off Ebuyer and I was left shockingly impressed. While we techy people often define how good we are by how little of the manual and help screens we use (why is that?) the promise of an “easy” install intrigued me. Popping in the cd i was led by the hand through a near flawless explanation of how to set everything up, the only flaw being my dad’s Macfee and Windows deciding not to tell me first time they had been blocking my connection.( I definitely didn’t check all the cables underneath my desk before realising this btw). The advanced options were there but  I really didn’t need them and as is pretty obvious I was left damn impressed.

   Amusingly there were no instructions  i could see telling me how to assemble the antennas on the router or where to put the screws for the stand. Also Ebuyer might have let me know the vouches offer was essentially over. Ah well can’t have everything.

 

PS the router performs pretty damn good as well :P

http://www.dlink.com/products/?pid=565

http://www.ebuyer.com/product/134991


But Liam! You didn’t mention the Wii…

March 27, 2008

It does seem odd that in my analysis and predication of the current video game market  I failed to mention the console that has sold the most units to date. Then again i don’t see the Wii as a major threat to Microsoft and Sony despite shockingly  successful hardware sales.

   My reasoning is simply that the Wii is a party system. Well duh Liam that’s what half the marketing is aimed at!, but hear me out. A party system is just that, something you bring out at parties. Now ask yourself if you have a party lets say once every month are you going to go and buy a new game for the brief period your Wii is out during the evening? The launch title of Zelda made me think the Wii was going to go down both roads: hardcore gamer and casual but from the line up of games I’m not so sure anymore. Short of the regular couple Mario titles what else is going to attract the long term fan? Don;t get me wrong I’m impressed in the way Nintendo has made a niche for itself and is still managing to make profit (considering  its long term rival  Sega just quit) but  I cannot see the Wii making any real software sale numbers to compete with the 360 and PS3 for any long stretch of time. And thus despite the in your face hardware figures I don’t see Nintendo as a real threat to the majority of ‘gamer’ market sales.

  Then again that’s not really Nintendo’s aim is it? Wii Fit 16 player deathmatch anyone?


A Phone you can touch

March 26, 2008

While browsing Engadget last night I was rather disturbed to see the new LG-SH240 slider model. Or rather its unique characteristic and selling point of the touchpad “feeling” like human skin. Now my initial reaction was there’s thinking outside the box but the general idea is to stay within the solar system of said box. I mean can you imagine the board meeting

Tim: “Right guys, we’ve done the posh with the Prada we need a new angle..any ideas…?

Sam:”Well ..Jim here had a good idea

Jim:Oh er well…we could always…

However the more  i think about it the less obscure it sounds. We’ve done looks, sound and most phones have the same features now. What else can you do with a phone? With the release of the iphone apparently being god’s gift to the world its not that surprising  that someone like LG would want to do something a little different. And hey I’d rather they focused on touch than the other currently non used senses…

lg


The console war – is it already over?

March 26, 2008

The current console war is just beginning to heat up, despite Sony’s slow start with the Playstation 3 they are beginning to get their bandwagon moving and early adopters are starting to get some justification behind their elaborately priced living room black centrepiece. However I believe the 360 has already proven itself the winner…

   From an outside perspective this console war bares a strange symmetry to its predecessor . Sega and their now failed Dreamcast were the first ‘next- gen’ console of the time, and despite some great ideas in both software and hardware the force of Sony’s “all powerful” console on the horizon shut down any hope of a Sega revival following the Saturn. The same set up seemed to be in place this time around, with Microsoft launching the 360 years before the PS3. However Microsoft took advantage of this beyond anything  I could have expected , so much so that upon the PS3’s arrival it was greeted by mocking and jeers over its shortcomings now, rather than its later potential benefits. Something very much unlike  previous Sony consoles.

   This is not to say that the PS3 will not do well this generation or that it will indeed not win the war. As much as  I love my 360 (despite it currently being broken grr) I held back on wanting one for over a year simply because there was nothing on it that made me want to shell out hundreds of pounds. Gears of War (and to a smaller extent Geometry Wars) finally made me take the plunge and now  I have a 360 collection comprising of some of the best and most enjoyable games I have ever played. The PS3 however has just itself passed its first year mark and slowly things are beginning to look in its favour.

   The next Hi Def format war was importantly handed to the blue corner and for many people taking the “wait and see” approach the Playstation 3 now presents far more value and security for money. Sony have talked about the Playstation 3 being a very long term project whereas rumour would have it Microsoft will be releasing a new Xbox console in 2-3 years. Again the once laughably high price tag of the PS3 is beginning to seem like an increasingly more reasonable investment.

   There is however still the issue of a lack of games on this now branded ‘ Sony entertainment system’: however the games will come. Experience has thought me that the important thing in a console war is selling the main hardware. Again taking the Dreamcast as an example, in my opinion the greatest game to ever grace the earth (Shenmue) was so expensive it would have required every Dreamcast owner to buy the game twice to turn profit. A company cannot afford to spend millions making great games if the risk of not seeing returns is too high, with the possible exception of Microsoft. Sony are now selling a high volume of consoles even beating the 360 console sales in recent months (although 360 shortages are often passed as the reason) . Even if people aren’t playing ‘ the best games’ out their at the moment on their Playstation 3, Sony have a market share which they can sell their top titles to once they are released.

   In my opinion despite my 360 ownership and my enjoyment of it  i believe by sales figures come the end of this gen’s war Sony will seem to have been the winner. It will be a little hard to clarify this due to Microsoft undoubtedly launching another console before the PS3 is near its downward cycle but  i think Sony will get the nod. However this does not necessarily mean that Sony were victorious this generation, far from it.

  Back when i heard Microsoft were making their own console some laughed  and saw no way for them to be successful  as everyone seemed to own a PS2. However Microsoft had what possibly no other company had, i.e. more money than Sony. Microsoft forced their way into the saturated market buy brute force and, despite the last gen belonging to Sony, grabbed an important foothold. The 360 however has been such a success- the USA is happy to embrace a non Sony console again, Europe is now not a walk in the park for the Playstation and Japan … well ok Japan still loves Sony but Microsoft have moved forward this generation will great purpose. Not just in sales either, they have relations with developers and publishers that were previously exclusive to Sony. A classic example being the awesome Assassins Creed that Ubisoft were willing to give  exclusivity rights to Sony on a plate. Sony tried to play their hand but unlike before when Sony dominance of such a large market share would mean publishers would have little leeway. Microsoft provided an other option.

   For me the next generation could really go either way and begin the downfall of Sony if they do not learn from their mistakes. The gaming division of Sony made terrible losses in preparing for the PS3 and their marketing seems to just be to growl and hope that everybody stops and takes notice. Sony cannot rest on their laurels. Microsoft, whatever you might think of the company, has made great effort to build an Xbox community- helped greatly by the face of Major Nelson. Xbox live has gone from being a add on to the main reason many buy games. If Sony want to stay in competition after the next generation they in my opinion need to pat themselves on the back and then move on. You became successful.. well done! now look at your rivals and learn from their mistakes and triumphs, don’t just tell the fans your better; show them as well.

  Like  I said before this console war will be won on figures by Sony but the real winner in my opinion is still the rapidly growing Microsoft beast the Xbox.